25 Sandwich Bread Recipes for Any Sandwich
Looking for the best sandwich breads? Yes, white bread is an awesome choice but don't miss the opportunity to try something different. These are my best recipes for making perfect sandwich rolls, loaves, and focaccias for any sandwich you can imagine.
A great sandwich always starts with the bread. Whether you're looking for a loaf that is soft and fluffy or hearty with a hint of sourdough tang, choosing just the right sandwich bread can transform your lunch.
As the author of The Ultimate Bread Machine Cookbook, I've tested dozens upon dozens of sandwich breads. Some are baked right in the bread maker, some are prepped as dough and then baked off in the oven.
My collection of sandwich breads includes an option for just about any sandwich filling you can imagine. I encourage you to try something a little outside your regular routine and watch how much more excited you'll get about that packed sandwich at lunch time.
Bread Machine Sandwich Breads
I love to use my Cuisinart bread maker when I'm baking a bread machine sandwich loaf because it has such a uniform shape for slicing.
If you've got a copy of my bread maker cookbook, in addition to the recipes listed in this article you could also bake:
- Milk & Honey Bread, page 17
- Brown Sugar Oatmeal Bread, page 18
- Honey Whole Wheat Bread, page 21
- Caraway Rye Bread, page 26
- Speedy Sourdough Loaf, page 33
- Rosemary Herb Bread, page 39
- Farmer's Market Veggie Patch Bread, page 40
- Savory Sweet Potato Bread, page 44
- Sun-dried Tomato Parmesan Bread, page 48
- and sooooo many more!
You can buy your own copy right here!
White Bread Recipes
If I asked you to imagine the perfect sandwich bread, chances are really likely you'd picture a classic white bread in some form or another.
But white breads don't have to always fall into the "soft and fluffy" category, sometimes they can be crusty, tangy, or hearty.
Whether you're making a grilled sandwich with a crispy crust or you just want something to gently sink your teeth into, I've got the perfect white bread for you.
Bread Machine White Bread
Soft, buttery, and perfectly fluffy, this bread machine white bread is the ultimate sandwich bread because it will pair with just about any sandwich fillings you want to tuck inside.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Peanut butter and jelly
- Grilled cheese with tomato soup
- Turkey or ham and cheese
Bread Machine Italian Bread
My easy bread machine Italian bread is a classic white bread made with milk in the dough for a little added richness. This neutral flavored bread is perfect for sandwiches that run either sweet or savory.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Chicken pesto sandwich
- Caprese sandwich with mozzarella and tomatoes
Bread Machine French Bread
My bread machine French bread is a dairy-free bread made with just water, olive oil, flour, and salt. Softer and more easily sliced than a baguette from the store, this is an excellent option for just about any sandwich.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Butter and prosciutto
- Open face tuna melt
- Griddled croque monsieur
Bread Machine Ciabatta
Rustic and full of air pockets, my bread machine ciabatta gives sandwiches an artisan cafe feel. The chewy crust and hearty crumb can stand up to moist fillings without getting soggy.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Try brushing it with olive oil and toasting before building a Cuban pulled pork sandwich
- Open face cheesy crab melts
- Roasted veggies with a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette and provolone
Bread Machine Potato Bread
Soft and tender bread machine potato bread has just a hint of sweetness from the instant potato flakes used in the dough. This cozy white bread is extra comforting when toasted lightly.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Chicken salad sandwich
- Cranberry chicken salad sandwich
- Classic BLT
English Muffin Bread
My English muffin bread is mixed up in a regular bowl, no fancy equipment needed. It is the ultimate breakfast sandwich bread but you can also use it later in the day for lunch or dinner.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Eggs, bacon, and cheese sandwich
- Toasted peanut butter and apples sandwich
- Avocado, tomato, and sprouts
Bread Machine Challah Loaf
While most challah breads are braided into stunning shapes, my easy bread machine challah is baked as a simple sandwich loaf that slices perfectly. This is an excellent option for delicate sandwich fillings or a stuffed French toast sandwich.
Sandwich Suggestions:
Whole Wheat Breads
Now if I asked you to imagine a sandwich on whole wheat bread, what would be your reaction?
If you assume you don't enjoy whole wheat bread, I challenge you to think again. Homemade whole wheat loaves are so much more tender and delicious than the options you'll find at the grocery store.
I love to include a hint of honey or molasses for sweetener, too. I think you're going to love these options.
Bread Machine Steakhouse Brown Bread
Soft, slightly sweet, and with that gorgeous deep brown color, my bread machine steakhouse brown bread is my favorite to pair with hearty meats and cheeses. I bet you'd never guess there's a little whole wheat in the mix!
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Roast beef and horseradish sauce
- Sliced ham with honey mustard
Bread Machine Rye Bread
Hearty and delicious, this easy bread machine rye bread gets its darker color from a touch of molasses which pairs so well with the caraway seeds. It bakes up strong but soft and can handle the griddle for hot sandwiches, too.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Classic or grilled turkey reubens
- Grilled turkey, apple, and cheddar sandwiches
- Grilled ham an havarti sandwiches
Sourdough Sandwich Breads
I know that sourdough fans will fight me over what I'm about to tell you:
There's a few times where sourdough is best made with a bread machine over traditional methods.
One of those times? A sourdough sandwich bread.
When you want a uniform loaf that slices neatly from end to end, what better way to bake sourdough than in a bread maker?
Want to Save This for Later?
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
Garlic Parmesan Sourdough
If you've got sourdough starter to work with, you'll want to make my bread machine garlic parmesan sourdough bread for sandwiches soon. The subtle tang from the sourdough pairs really well with hearty fillings.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Vegetable panini with baby spinach and roasted peppers
- Toast it and pair with my hot honey chicken and slaw
Sandwich Rolls
A sandwich doesn't always have to be tucked between to flat slices of bread, mixing things up and using a sandwich roll once in a while can make your lunch more delicious.
Whole Wheat Hamburger Buns
If you're grilling up a burger or want to layer in thick cuts of leftover meat to make a sandwich, you need a hearty bun that can keep up. My easy whole wheat hamburger buns pair perfectly with a long list of options. Here are some of my favorites.
Sandwich Suggestions:
Focaccia Breads
Hearty focaccia bread makes an amazing sandwich bread but most people forget about it here in the US.
Bake up a loaf of homemade focaccia in a small baking pan so it rises high and thick. Slice it in half for a sandwich you can really get a grip on.
The golden brown olive oil crust holds up perfectly to pressing in a panini grill if you want, too!
Bread Machine Focaccia
If you bake my bread machine focaccia in a smaller baking pan, it will bake up into thicker pieces that you can halve for amazing focaccia sandwiches.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Pressed mozzarella, tomato, and basil panini
- Ham and provolone with arugula
Sourdough Focaccia
If you want that bakery-style chew and a rustic crust with the subtle tang from sourdough, you'll love my easy sourdough focaccia. bread for a hearty open face sandwich.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Grilled chicken with pesto and sun dried tomatoes
- Hummus, cucumbers, and feta
Breads for Holiday Leftovers Sandwiches
When Thanksgiving, Christmas, or Easter are all over and you open up your fridge to see those glorious containers of leftovers, what's the first thing that comes to mind??
A holiday leftovers sandwich, of course!
These fresh breads bring a whole new life to those sliced meats, gravies, and sauces.
Bread Machine Celery Seed Bread
I love the unique flavor of this easy bread machine celery seed bread. It would pair really well with most holiday roasts for making sandwiches the next day:
- Spiral ham
- Roasted turkey
- Roast beef
Bread Machine Stuffing Bread
While I normally make my bread machine stuffing bread to make my mom's Italian sausage stuffing for Thanksgiving, you don't have to cube it up for homemade croutons. Bake it and slice it for the best leftover Thanksgiving sandwiches ever!
Sandwich Suggestion:
Bread Machine Cornmeal Stuffing Bread
If you're more of a cornbread stuffing fan, I've got you covered. Bake this bread machine cornmeal stuffing bread and layer it with leftover cranberry sauce and sliced Thanksgiving turkey for your sandwiches the next day.
Sweet Breads
I love the complementary flavors when sweet is paired with savory. Don't underestimate the power of these delicately sweetened breads to bring joy to your sandwich plate.
Pair them with just the right fillings and you'll never want a plain bread again!
Maple Oatmeal Bread
You can pair a sweet bread with a savory filling and there's no better example than my delicious bread machine maple oatmeal bread. The cozy hint of maple syrup pairs really with with savory fillings, especially ham or sausage.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Ham and cheddar
- Sliced pork tenderloin with Dijon
Bread Machine Raisin Bread
Want to really switch up your sandwich game? Try using a homemade raisin bread for something totally new?
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Cream cheese with apple slices and/or turkey
- Peanut butter and banana slices
Bread Machine Apple Bread
This smooth crumbed bread machine apple bread makes an excellent slicing loaf for sandwiches. While the apple flavor makes the bread sweet, it would still pair perfectly with more savory fillings.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Turkey and brie
- Ham and cheddar
- Almond butter and sliced apples
French Pear Bread
This yeasted bread machine French pear bread has just a hint of black pepper which keeps the loaf from running too sweet for a sandwich.
Sandwich Suggestions:
- Prosciutto and brie
More Bread Recipes
Comments
No Comments