Irish Potato Soup

Why This is the Best Recipe

My oldest daughter and I spent a week in Ireland with her school marching band. This soup is inspired by the first course we enjoyed for several nights in a row at one of our favorite restaurants.

She and I agree this is the best Irish potato soup recipe because:

1. Just Like Ireland!: I chatted with the server at the restaurant to get an idea of what might be in the soup. I took those notes and then did some research in authentic Irish cookbooks. Based on what I knew and what we have available to buy here in the states, I created this soup to be as close to that real Irish soup as possible. We think we nailed it!
2. Cozy and Comforting: If you need comfort food, this is it. The pureed soup is so easy to eat and goes down smooth and cozy when you're feeling under the weather on a chilly day.
3. Easy to Tweak: The restaurant served this soup every night so they could use up whatever leftover vegetables they had from the night before. Sometimes we tasted broccoli, sometimes more carrots. You could add a wide variety of veggies to this and it would still taste great.

Ingredients

Irish food is so wholesome and real. To make this farmhouse style soup, all you need is:

• Potatoes: I used russet potatoes because they seem to be the closest thing we have in the United States to the kind of potatoes they use most frequently in Ireland.
• Carrots: The whole carrot has a better flavor than baby carrots, but either would work.
• Celery
• Leek: I love the taste of a fresh leek but if you can't find them, you could use a regular onion or a Vidalia sweet onion.
• Frozen Peas: Regular frozen peas is the classic ingredients but honestly a bag of frozen mixed vegetables would work, great too!
• Chicken Stock
• Heavy Cream or Half and Half: I'm fairly certain that Irish restaurant used heavy cream, but I lightened our dinner up with half and half instead.
• Butter: Kerrygold Irish butter would be the absolute perfect choice here but use what you have.
• Dried Thyme & Sage: Fresh herbs would be even better if you have them. I don't have these individual spices in my pantry so I substituted a bit of poultry seasoning that features both of them instead.
• Cayenne Pepper: This is absolutely NOT a spicy soup. A tiny pinch of cayenne enhances the overall flavor of the soup without the need for too much salt. This is the one ingredient that is not truly authentic, but it definitely helps improve the soup.
• Salt & Pepper

Prep the Vegetables

It is really easy to prep the simple vegetables for this Irish potato soup.

The only exception is the fresh leek. If you've never cooked with fresh leeks before, you need to know that it is very important to cut the leeks and thoroughly wash them to remove the sand and grit that collects among all the layers.

I shared very detailed instructions for how to cut leeks and wash them here:

Once the leeks are prepped, you'll need to:

• peel and chop the potatoes
• peel and chop the carrots
• chop the celery

Saute the Vegetables

In a large soup pot, melt the butter over medium-high heat.

Add the leek and celery and cook for 5 - 7 minutes or until they've softened.

Add the diced potatoes and carrots and stir everything together.

Add the chicken stock, thyme, sage, and cayenne and stir.

Bring the mixture to a boil and cook for 25 minutes or until the potatoes are tender.

Add the frozen peas and let them warm in the soup for 1 minute.

Use an immersion blender to puree the soup until everything is quite smooth.

Add the cream and a pinch of salt and pepper.

Stir the soup and taste and adjust the seasonings as needed.

I love that you can still see tiny flecks of orange carrot swimming in that green soup, it showcases the mix of veggies hiding inside:

Variations

As I mentioned, this simple Irish potato soup was meant to be a homestyle vegetable soup that incorporates whatever the cook might have to use up in the fridge.

It is so delicious no matter what veggies you decide to puree inside.

You could add fresh or frozen:

• Broccoli
• Cauliflower
• Green Beans
• Parsnips
• Green Cabbage
• Zucchini
• Sweet Corn
• Spinach

Make Ahead Tips

With the use of heavy cream, this Irish potato soup is not freezer friendly. The cream will separate when the soup thaws.

However, the soup does reheat quite well the next day.

You can make this soup in advance up to 3 days from serving.

Store it in the fridge in a covered container and simply reheat it on the stove top.

You may need to thin the soup out a little with a splash of chicken stock if it thickens too much in the fridge.

A pureed soup like this farmhouse potato soup is really best for a first course or appetizer.

You could serve small bowls before a dinner of roasted pork loin, my tender pork in applesauce, or even a simple roasted chicken with vegetables.

If you want to make it a cozy lunch or a light dinner, you could serve it with homemade crescent rolls or rosemary dinner rolls for dipping.

For a heartier meal, add a batch of my easy baked sausage rolls or a tray of these buttery ham and cheese sliders.

Bread Machine Crescent Dinner Rolls

Easy Rosemary Pull Apart Rolls

Gooey Hawaiian Roll Ham and Cheese Sliders

Easy Spiced Sausage Rolls

More Irish Recipes

Traditional Irish food is filled with cozy dishes everyone will love.

Whether you're cooking a St. Patrick's Day dinner or just feel like a little taste of the Emerald Isle and want some truly authentic Irish recipes, you can't go wrong with these tasty dishes:

Irish Beef Pot Pie

Easy Fried Cabbage with Caraway Seeds

Irish Soda Bread with Raisins {Oven or Bread Machine}

Make-Ahead Apple Slab Pie

More Soup Recipes

Soup Season is a year-round thing in our household. If you love veggie-filled soups for your family, don't mis out on some of our favorite recipes:

Split Pea and Carrot Soup with Leftover Ham

Sweet and Sour Cabbage Soup {Stovetop or Crockpot}

Ina's Chicken Pot Pie Soup For Frugal Families

Easy Italian Wedding Soup {Instant Pot or Stovetop}