Pulled Pork in the Oven or Slow Cooker

Why This is the Best

This flexible pulled pork recipe is the best because:

1. Oven or Slow Cooker: You can choose how you want to cook it depending on your schedule, I love it both ways!
2. Not Too Spicy: The pulled pork rub that gets slathered over the roast before cooking is so delicious and very kid-friendly. The final pulled pork isn't too spicy for kids but could be adjusted if you like it hot.
3. Tender and Juicy: Both cooking methods keep the roast nice and tender, no dried out pork here!
4. Freezes Well: I love to freeze it in smaller portions for making lots of dinners during the season.
5. Feeds a Crowd: The recipe is easily adjusted for a larger or smaller pork roast and is perfect for a party.

The base ingredients for this shredded pork are so easy:

• Pork Shoulder Butt Roast: Depending on where you buy your meat, the roast can go by a lot of different names. I've used both bone-in and boneless, but the bone-in is a lot more tender and delicious.
• Chicken Stock or Water
• The Best Pulled Pork Rub: See note below.

Best Pulled Pork Rub

It is crucial to season the pork before you add it to the pot for cooking.

As the pork roasts over several hours, the seasonings flavor the meat and make it extra delicious.

This pork rub recipe uses both dry spices and fresh onion to form a wet paste that gets slathered over the roast.

To make it, you will need:

• Onion
• Minced Garlic
• Olive Oil
• White Wine Vinegar
• Brown Sugar
• Cumin*
• Oregano*

*I've included the recipe for using individual spices but sometimes when I'm feeling extra-lazy, I use a prepared mix of chipotle barbecue rub instead of the individually measured spices.

If you have a special blend you love, it is ok to add it into the mix but definitely still use the fresh onion and garlic!

Should You Rinse the Pork?

There has been a lot of recent debate over whether or not you should rinse your raw meat before cooking.

Since this recipe cooks for such a long time, rinsing isn't absolutely necessary but my husband still prefers when I take this extra step.

If you decide to rinse your meat, use cold water on low pressure to reduce splashing and be sure to scour your sink after the roast is in the oven.

I place the roast on a clean plate in my sink and just gently drizzle the cold water over the sides to rinse it.

Always pat it completely dry with paper towels before applying the rub to the sides.

Which is Best: Oven or Slow Cooker?

I've made this pork both in the oven and in my slow cooker and there are pros and cons to both methods.

Use the Oven If:

• You want crispy edges to the finished meat. There is no way to get this in a slow cooker without transferring to the oven which can be a messy process.
• You'll be home to watch it.
• You are willing to turn it over once every hour.
• You have a heavy dutch oven with a well fitting lid.
• You're eating it for at least one meal before freezing it.

Use the Slow Cooker If:

• You want to set it and forget it until it is done.
• You want to cook it overnight.
• You won't be home to watch it.
• You prefer tender meat with no crispy edges.
• You're prepping it for the freezer immediately.

Be sure to check the recipe card for full cooking instructions for both methods.

Make Ahead Freezer Tips

If you are prepping the pork ahead for a future meal, there are a few tricks to ensuring it remains tender.

Before you freeze the pulled pork be sure to:

• Shred the meat.
• Let the meat completely cool.
• Split it into smaller portions if you want to be able to heat just enough for a single dinner without thawing the whole batch.
• Store it in an airtight container.

Reheating Pulled Pork

To avoid your pork drying out during the reheating process, it is best to let the frozen pork thaw in the fridge overnight.

Cooking it from frozen requires more heat over a longer period and has a greater chance of overcooking the pork.

Starting the warming process with already thawed meat means less time in the oven or microwave.

For a large portion of pork, I like to store it in an aluminum pan that can go straight to the oven.

For smaller portions, I prefer using plastic baggies. Once the meat has thawed, I transfer it to my favorite glass dishes with lids for reheating.

To reheat the pulled pork, be sure to drizzle a little chicken stock over the top to help steam the meat and keep it tender as it warms.

Keep it covered and cook at just 250°F until it is warmed through.

There are 3 ways I love to serve pulled pork:

1. Pulled Pork Plate: A traditional Southern way to serve barbecue, serve the pulled pork on a plate with several delicious sides to go with it.
2. Pulled Pork Sandwiches: Piled high on a toasted bun, with or without BBQ sauce and coleslaw. You could also turn it into pulled pork sliders just like this BBQ chicken slider recipe.
3. Pulled Pork Stuffed Potatoes: Top a baked potato with a pile of pulled pork just like these chicken taco chili potatoes. Add BBQ sauce, shredded cheddar and a dollop of sour cream and fresh green onions or chives.

If you're looking for a super smart meal plan trick, save some of the leftover pork to make my easy Cuban sliders another night!

Pulled Pork Sides

If you decide to make a pulled pork plate with sides, you need super delicious ideas to go with it!

These are some of our favorite pulled pork sides: