This foolproof bread maker pizza dough recipe is ready with just 5 minutes of hands-on time. Add the simple ingredients to your bread machine, press START and a fresh baked homemade pizza will be at your fingertips by dinnertime.
Pizza is practically it's own food group in our family. My husband's love for it is so strong, it got mention during the Best Man's speech at our wedding. So to say we are picky about our pizza would be an understatement.
While we may argue about which toppings make the best pizza, we can all agree you can't have a perfect pizza without a perfect pizza crust.
This homemade bread maker pizza dough is the best you'll find because it only takes a few minutes to measure and add the ingredients to your bread machine bread pan. Simply press the Start button and walk away. The dough will be waiting for you at dinnertime.
When you're ready to roll out the dough, you'll find this pizza crust is easy to form and bakes up with a perfectly crispy crust as long as you follow these tips for how to bake pizza dough in your oven.
🍶Ingredients You Need
This slightly seasoned bread machine pizza dough has a very short list of ingredients:
- Bread flour: We use King Arthur Baking flour for almost all of our bread machine recipes. It gives consistent results and I find it rises better than other brands we've used. Don't want to purchase bread flour? See the substitutions section below.
- Extra virgin olive oil: The olive oil will go inside the dough itself as well as get brushed over the pizza crust edge before baking. Make sure you have extra virgin olive oil.
- Instant yeast: This is the only yeast we use in our bread makers. I buy Saf-Instant yeast in bulk and keep it in a storage container in our freezer because we go through it so quickly. If you don't plan to bake often, the individual packets are fine.
- Water: Straight from the tap will be just fine.
- Kosher salt: Do not substitute table salt or the saltiness will be off.
- Dry Romano Cheese Spice Blend (OPTIONAL): I've fallen in love with this Taylor Street Garlic & Herb Seasoning from The Spice House. I add just a teaspoon to the dough and it gives it a little hint of extra savory flavor. It isn't essential but my whole family loves it.
😋The Texture & Taste
With so few ingredients, the pizza dough will really take on the flavor of the olive oil you use. This is why it is essential to use a high-quality olive oil.
The dough makes 2 12-inch pizza crusts. At that size, the thickness of the pizza crust is similar to a hand-tossed pizza at your favorite pizza delivery place. If you roll your pizzas out larger or smaller, this will affect the bake time and final texture.
The texture of the crust is crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside if you follow my baking instructions in the recipe card.
🍞How to Fill the Bread Pan
If you've never used your bread maker before, the most essential thing to know before you begin is that you ALWAYS add the ingredients to the bread pan in the order they are listed in the recipe.
If you add them in a different order, it will negatively affect the way the bread machine mixes the dough.
The liquids always go in first: Make sure the paddle attachment is in place before you add the water and the olive oil to the pan.
Next, the flour gets added to the pan. At this point, I strongly encourage you to use a food scale to measure the flour. This helps ensure your pizza dough will come out perfectly.
I place the bread pan on the food scale and then turn the scale on. The scale should read "0" but if it doesn't, look for a button that says "Tare" to zero-out the scale. Now you'll be able to add the flour one large spoonful at a time until you get the proper weight.
Add the salt in the corners of the pan, don't dump it right in the middle of the flour. This helps to make sure the yeast and the salt don't touch directly which can kill the yeast and prevent your pizza dough from rising.
If you're using the optional seasoning, add that to the corner of the pan as well.
Lastly, use the back of a spoon to dig a shallow well in the center of the flour. This is where you'll put the yeast.
Once you've added the yeast, the pan is ready for your bread maker.
🗒️Tips for Using A Bread Maker
Secure the bread pan into place and then select the DOUGH program. Some machines have multiple options for making dough. You don't need "Artisan Dough" or "Crusty Bread", just the regular "Dough" option will be perfect.
For the 5 models of bread machines we tested, the Dough program took 1 hour and 30 minutes on each of them.
First, you bread machine will mix together the dough and form a rough dough ball. This takes just a few minutes and is really the only stage where you should keep an eye on the progress.
Even if you measure correctly and weigh your flour, sometimes there's just not enough moisture for the dough ball to properly mix. If your dough is looking dry and shaggy, add a little extra water just 1 teaspoon at a time until the dough comes together and isn't sticking on the sides of the bread pan.
This is what the dough looks like when it is too dry:
See how the dough is sticking to the sides of the pan? Also notice how the dough looks craggy and clumpy.
I added just ONE teaspoon of extra water and then dough came together and looked like this:
See how there's no more dough sticking to the sides of the pan? Now the dough ball looks smooth and complete.
If your pizza dough ball doesn't look like that within the first 4 minutes of mixing, add just a little sprinkle of water and scrape the sides of the bread pan with a non-stick safe spatula, making sure to keep the spatula away from the turning paddle.
Once your dough ball has come together, shut the lid of the bread maker and you're free to do anything else you want for the next hour and thirty minutes.
When the Dough program is complete, your pizza dough should have risen and mostly filled your bread maker pan. The dough should be soft and smooth looking look like this:
⏱️Prepare the Second Rise
You're almost there! Your pizza dough is now properly prepared but it needs one more little step before you bake with it.
Brush the inside of a large mixing bowl with extra virgin olive oil. Transfer the pizza dough to the bowl and gently press it with your fingers to deflate it.
Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and place it in a warm place to do a second rise.
I like to place the bowl on my stovetop. When I preheat the oven for baking the pizza, the bit of warmth helps the dough rise just a little more before I work with it.
After another hour, your dough should have doubled in size like this:
Now you're ready to shape and bake your homemade pizza!
💭Recipe FAQs and Substitutions
Bread flour has a higher protein content than regular all purpose flour does. If you substitute them, it may affect the rise of the dough but it should still work. Keep an extra careful watch on the mixing phase of the bread machine, the dough may be dryer with all purpose flour and you may have to add a little more water to get the right consistency.
Yes, bread machine yeast is the same as instant yeast and can be used interchangeably in your bread maker in a 1:1 ratio.
There are 2 ¼ teaspoons in a single packet of instant yeast. This recipe calls for just 2 teaspoon so you won't want to use the entire packet. Measure out the 2 teaspoon and discard the remaining yeast. This is the greatest benefit of buying your yeast in bulk. You can always measure just what you need without wasting any leftover.
🍽️How to Store the Pizza Dough
If you don't want to bake pizza right away, this dough keeps perfectly in the fridge for several days.
Make the Dough Ahead:
Follow the recipe right up to the point where the bread maker has completed the Dough program. Transfer the pizza dough to a mixing bowl that comes with a lid. Brush the bowl with olive oil.
Turn the dough over once so the ball is coated in oil and cover the surface of the dough with plastic wrap. This will help keep the dough fresh and prevent it from drying out. Place the lid on the bowl and place the bowl in your fridge for storage.
How to Use Pre-Made Pizza Dough:
Your pizza dough isn't quite ready-to-go at this point. It still needs to do the second rise.
On the night you want to bake pizza, simply take the bowl out of your fridge 2 hours before you want to cook so it has time to come to room temperature and then finish the second rise.
Remove the lid and surface plastic wrap. Cover the bowl with a clean towel or a fresh piece of plastic wrap and place the bowl in a warm place to rise.
Soon you'll be ready to roll out the pizza crust and get dinner started.
If you’ve tried this bread maker pizza dough or any other recipe on PeanutBlossom.com please don’t forget to rate the recipe and let me know where you found it in the comments below. I love hearing from you!
FOLLOW along on Instagram @peanut.blossom as well as on Pinterest and Facebook.