Tzatziki Sauce for Gyros

Why This is the Best Recipe

Yes, you could buy tzatziki at the store in a prepared tub, but making your own homemade takes just a few minutes and tastes so much better.

The prepared yogurt tzatziki, even from the best places, has an odd tang to it that I can only attribute to the preservatives.

My homemade version is better because:

1. Whole, Easy Ingredients: Check out the ingredients list below, you only need a short list of things and you probably have most of them in your pantry or fridge right now.
2. Adjust the Garlic: If you like things SUPER garlicky or you only like a hint, you can adjust the level of garlic to your family's preferences.
3. Adjust the Lemon: I like mine nice and zippy but if you prefer a more creamy, cool flavor, you can reduce the lemon juice.
4. Play with Herbs: Traditionally tzatziki does not have any fresh herbs mixed in but I personally love a little fresh dill or chopped chives.

Ingredients

Look at that easy pile of ingredients! All you need to make this recipe is:

• Greek Yogurt: I love to use a lighter 2% yogurt but you can use whole yogurt or fat-free if you prefer.
• Fresh Cucumber: Grab an English cucumber or a hothouse cucumber because they are seedless.
• Minced Garlic: I use this ingredient because it is so convenient. You could substitute fresh garlic if you prefer.
• Lemon
• White Wine Vinegar
• Salt & Pepper

Tzatziki Sauce with Sour Cream

One of the easiest variations you can make for this gyro sauce is to substitute sour cream for the Greek yogurt.

I usually use the Greek yogurt because it is naturally thicker than sour cream and holds up well to the addition of lemon juice, vinegar, and cucumber.

However, if you prefer to use sour cream, there are two options:

1. Thinner Gyro Sauce: If you use sour cream straight from the container, your tzatziki sauce will have a thinner, saucier consistency than the yogurt version. This is an excellent choice if you plan to drizzle the tzatziki over a gyro or a Greek pizza.
2. Strain the Sour Cream: If you want to use sour cream but you still want a thicker sauce, you'll need to strain some of the liquid from the sour cream by lining a colander with clean cheese cloth and placing it over a bowl. Let the sour cream sit on the cloth in the fridge overnight and some of the liquid will separate and be collected in the bowl below. Discard that liquid and use the thickened sour cream in place of the yogurt in the recipe below.

In either case, it is a 1:1 ratio for substitution. Simply use the same amount of sour cream as is called for Greek yogurt.

How to Grate the Cucumber

The most important step in making homemade tzatziki sauce for gyros is to properly prepare the fresh cucumber.

Cucumbers naturally have a LOT of liquid in them. If you grate the cucumber and add it immediately to the yogurt, you risk having a watery yogurt sauce.

To avoid that, simply start by grating the cucumber with a box grater over a clean plate.

I use the medium-grate side.

Look at how much liquid collects on the plate just when I finished the grating process:

Then, firmly press the cucumber against the plate squeezing as much liquid off of it as you can:

Make the Sauce

The final step is the easiest: simply mix everything together!

In a medium mixing bowl, add the Greek yogurt or sour cream.

Then add the garlic, lemon juice, white wine vinegar, salt and pepper and stir.

If your tzatziki sauce is still too thick for your liking, you can always add a little drizzle of extra lemon juice or a touch of olive oil to thin it out.

My favorite way to serve tzatziki sauce is drizzled over a warm gyro. I absolutely love making light chicken gyros with fresh tomatoes, red onion, and cucumber sauce.

If you're trying to skip the pita, you could serve this cucumber sauce alongside our favorite chicken tenderloins in the air fryer. This spicy seasoned tandoori marinated chicken in the air fryer pairs so well with the creamy sauce, too.

Or try this Greek chicken bowl with fresh veggies.