This homemade cinnamon swirl bread can be cut into slices for the best toast you’ve ever had and tastes just like a warm cinnamon bun with a rich, cinnamon-packed filling.
I have been craving homemade cinnamon buns for MONTHS.
First, there was a run on yeast. Then I couldn’t find bread flour to save my life. When I was finally able to refill my pantry, the first recipe I tried resulted in overly crumby rolls that didn’t taste anything at all like the smooth, chewy cinnamon roll dough I’ve been dreaming of.
I reached out to my friend Melissa who happens to be an amazing home baker and mom of four strapping teenage boys. If anyone would have a reliable recipe for cinnamon buns, it was sure to be her.
(Be sure to stop by and say hi at her 4 Boys Mother blog!)
I knew I asked the right person when her response was: Cinnamon rolls can be such a pain. You need to bake this cinnamon swirl bread instead! It is so much easier but has all the same flavors.
Easier? Same flavors? Ok, SOLD.
This bread was so fantastic, I had to pass on the favor and share it with you. Add it to your baking rotation stat and you can thank us later.
Homemade Cinnamon Swirl Bread for Beginner Bakers:
Normally, I prefer to make homemade bread in my bread machine. Measure the ingredients, dump in the bowl, done. You can find my favorite bread machine recipes here.
However, this particular bread recipe requires making the dough in your stand mixer and rolling it out by hand. But don’t let that scare you!
It may have a few more steps than a normal bread machine recipe, but I pinkie swear it was so much easier to do than cinnamon rolls, for sure.
What ingredients do I need to make cinnamon swirl bread?
There are three unique ingredients you’ll need in your pantry to make this cinnamon swirl bread:
- Baker’s Cinnamon Filling Mix: This is a specialty item you need to buy from King Arthur but is absolutely worth the effort.
- Powdered dry milk: Easily found at your grocery store or you can order it from King Arthur here.
- Instant yeast: Either packets or bulk yeast. I used this brand of yeast.
The only thing that made me hesitate with Melissa’s recommendation was the declaration that it is absolutely essential to order the Baker’s Cinnamon Filling mix from King Arthur Flour. I’m not generally keen on recipes that have a required hard-to-find ingredient I can’t get at my local grocery store, but her rave review of the recipe had me curious.
I ordered the cinnamon filling and gave it a try. I immediately saw why Melissa loves it so. I can add my hearty agreement that it is worth the extra step.
You simply measure out enough of the Baker’s Cinnamon Filling Mix and just add water. Stir together the mixture with a fork and you’ve got instant cinnamon filling that will remind you immediately of a Cinnabon.
You will also need powdered dry milk. I ordered it from King Arthur Flour at the same time as the cinnamon mix but that particular ingredient can be found fairly easily at most grocery stores and is very inexpensive.
Lastly, instant yeast is essential for this recipe. If you’ve done any bread baking at all, you’ll be familiar with this ingredient. If this is your first attempt at bread-baking, you need to choose between buying yeast in packets or a larger quantity of jarred or packaged yeast.
Which yeast do I use for this homemade bread?
If this is your first time buying yeast, you’ll just need to choose one of these options:
Instant Yeast Packets:
- Pros: The yeast stays fresh in single-portion packets. You’ll use one packet for this bread recipe.
- Cons: You’ll have to rip open more than one packet for some recipes and may have some waste. You’ll also have far less yeast on hand if you find you really enjoy bread baking.
Jarred or Packaged Instant Yeast:
- Pros: You can measure exactly the yeast you need for each recipe and always have plenty on hand.
- Cons: Once you open the container and expose the yeast to the air, you’ll need to use the yeast before it expires. Store it in the fridge to help extend its life.
If yeast is still difficult for you to find, just buy whatever instant yeast you can get your hands on. It will all work. I was able to add the SAF Red Instant Yeast to my order at King Arthur. This was a new-to-me brand, so I’m extra glad I also ordered this storage container. Once you open the SAF package, it is nearly impossible to store the yeast properly without some sort of container.
How to make the cinnamon swirl bread:
Good news for beginner bakers: this dough is really easy to work with. It is soft and pliable and super-easy to roll out.
To assemble the swirl bread, you roll out the dough to a large rectangle, spread the cinnamon filling over the top leaving an inch-wide border around the perimeter.
Roll the bread up tightly starting at the narrow end. Place the rolled log of dough in a bread pan and bake.
The loaf popped easily right out of my buttered bread pan. It cuts cleanly into neat slices.
Our family enjoyed it warm from the oven with just a little slather of butter for good measure. The next morning, we toasted it for breakfast and it heated up perfectly.
Could kids bake this cinnamon bread?
I let my kids help in the kitchen with just about any recipe if they are showing interest.
I haven’t done much work with yeasted doughs, but of the recipes I’ve tried, this bread is one of the easiest. I think it would be a perfect place to start in introducing homemade bread to kids.
They will love to spread the cinnamon mix and roll up the final loaf. It is just hands-on enough to be fun without being too intense with the steps.
The recipe for this bread is featured on the packaging of the cinnamon mix but I tweaked it to add more information for beginner bakers. I’ve found that traditional shorthand recipes tend to leave out crucial steps that kids or new bakers need to find success.
You should find everything you need to bake the bread perfectly here:
- 3 cups all-purpose flour (King Arthur brand is highly recommended)
- 1 1/4 tsp salt
- 2 1/2 tsp instant yeast
- 3 tbsp butter, softened
- 2 tbsp nonfat dry milk
- 3 tbsp sugar
- 1 cup water, lukewarm temperature
For the cinnamon filling:
- 3/4 cup Baker's Cinnamon Filling Mix
- 3 tbsp water
- MAKE THE DOUGH IN YOUR MIXER:
- Add all the ingredients for the bread dough (not the filling ingredients) to the bowl of an electric stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment. Stir on medium speed to combine thoroughly, about 3 minutes.
- Once the dough comes together, stop the mixer and swap the paddle attachment for the dough hook attachment. Knead the dough on medium speed until it is smooth and soft, about 5 - 7 minutes.
- LET THE DOUGH RISE:
- Form the dough into a ball and place it back in the bottom of the mixing bowl, cover with plastic wrap, and allow to rise for 1 1/2 hours.
- ASSEMBLE THE BREAD:
- Grease an 8.5 x 4.5-inch bread pan with a bit of softened butter or baking spray.
- Lightly flour your working surface and roll the dough into an 8 x 24-inch rectangle.
- In a small bowl, combine the Baker's Cinnamon Filling Mix with the water. Stir together with a fork until smooth. Spread the filling over the surface of the dough rectangle, leaving a 1-inch border around the edge.
- Roll the dough tightly, starting at the shorter edge of dough, to form a swirl log. Place it seam-side down inside your prepared baking pan.
- LET THE BREAD RISE AGAIN:
- Cover with plastic wrap and allow to rise for 2 hours or until it has risen barely 1-inch above the edge of the pan.
- BAKE THE BREAD:
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Bake the bread for 40 - 45 minutes. Place a bit of aluminum foil over the top after the first 20 minutes to prevent it from over-browning.
Cinnamon Filling Mix Note:
1 package of King Arthur's Baker's Cinnamon Filling Mix is enough to make 5 loaves of this recipe. Once opened, it should be stored in a cool, dry place or frozen in an airtight container for longer freshness.