20 Ice Cream Sundae Recipes

This post contains links to affiliate websites, such as Amazon, and we receive an affiliate commission for any purchases made by you using these links. We appreciate your support!

Be the mom of the year with this easy backyard sundae bar for kids! Lay out all the healthy (and not so healthy) ice cream toppings your kids will love in an easy-to-clean tray!

Budget friendly ice cream party buffet

I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream! Did you know that July is National Ice Cream Month?  Born and raised in the Dairy State, ice cream is by far one of my all time favorite treats.

I drool over those fabulous ice cream sundae bar parties you see all over the place but I never think to do something like that for just my own family. It feels wasteful and expensive to have all those little options available for topping that creamy treat. But the girls and I can never quite agree on which toppings to put in our bowl!

Then I had the perfect idea: Create an ice cream sundae bar that is reusable from week to week over the summer! Invest once in a few key ingredients and then maximize their use over time.

Plan the Sundae Bar

I made a list (you can find it at the bottom of this post) of ingredients that are:

  • shelf stable or freezable
  • able to be served in small portions
  • are both kid-friendly but fun for the adults, too
Budget friendly ice cream party buffet

Prep the Toppings

I carefully chopped and diced JUST enough for what we needed for one round of sundae topping and placed each ingredient in a separate silicone muffin cup placed in a muffin pan.

Yes, this makes it easy to carry to the table, but more importantly it's a cinch to pop the cups out of the pan to put the leftover toppings back into the container to store for next time.

Budget friendly ice cream party buffet

Build the Sundaes

I set the girls to work building their perfect ice cream sundae. I purposely put several cups of fruit and nuts in the tray and minimized the candy options.

If left to their own devices, their sundaes would look more like the candy aisle at the grocery store.

By selectively filling the tray, I'm encouraging them to try some healthier mix-ins.

For this round, they skipped right over the pineapple, raspberries, pecans, hazelnuts, and cashews for their bowls but when they were done with their treat, they ended up snacking on the fruit and nuts while we sat and chatted.

I think next time I'll wean them by filling the cups with even more fruit and less candy.

Budget friendly ice cream party buffet

It was so nice just setting out all the mom-approved options and sitting back letting them sprinkle to their hearts' content.

Once the cup was empty, that ingredient was gone.

Very small portions fit into the muffin cups so it isn't easy to go overboard with their topping.

Want to Save This for Later?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

Budget friendly ice cream party buffet

Easy Storage
Budget friendly ice cream party buffet

I put things away in stages.

Ice cream went back into the freezer first but we took our time nibbling on the fruit and nuts in the tray.

In the process, hands got sticky, faces got messy, and little dribbles fell on dresses.

Budget friendly ice cream party buffet

Then I set aside special plastic containers for the other leftover ingredients.

I'd never serve our leftovers to guests so I wanted to keep them in a separate "sundae bar stash".

The nuts went into their separate pouches, chopped up brownies into the freezer, and sprinkles back into a separate cup.

I stored it all together in the same spot in the pantry so the next time the mood strikes, everything will be ready and waiting for us!

Now don't forget to scroll down to see my list of toppings and 20 sundae "recipe" combinations!

Budget friendly ice cream party buffet

Essential Topping Recipes

Ice Cream Sauces: store in your fridge and heat as desired before using:

Chopped Nuts: store in separate pouches

  • pistachios
  • hazelnuts
  • pecans
  • cashews
  • peanuts
  • slivered almonds

Fresh Fruits: buy fresh before each sundae party or use canned!

  • strawberries
  • pineapple chunks
  • banana slices
  • blackberries
  • sweetened shredded coconut

Bakery Items: store in air tight plastic pouches or in the freezer!

I bought one package of brownies at our grocery store's bakery and plan to use it all summer long from the freezer. You can do the same with cookies, cake chunks, etc.

  • brownies
  • pound cake
  • Mini Oreos
  • crumbled cone pieces
  • vanilla wafers

Candy Bits: I went light on these because I wanted the kids to be more creative

  • chopped peanut butter cups
  • chopped dark chocolate bars

Garnishes: These all store well in the fridge or pantry except the mint which we grow right on our patio!

  • cinnamon sugar
  • whipped cream
  • maraschino cherries
  • sprinkles
  • fresh mint leaves

20 Ice Cream Sundae Combinations

I've sorted the list based on the flavor of the base ice cream. Be sure to have both chocolate and vanilla ice creams available.

Vanilla Ice Cream Base:

  • Turtle: hot fudge, caramel, salted pecans (my all time favorite!)
  • Peaches & Cream: peach jam, pound cake, slivered almonds
  • Cookies & Cream: hot fudge, Oreo
  • Strawberry Tart: strawberry, pistachios, vanilla wafers
  • Caramel Cashew: caramel, cashews, crumbled cone pieces
  • Banana split: marshmallow, bananas, raspberries, blackberries
  • Upside down pineapple cake: salted caramel, pineapple chunks, pound cake
  • Churro: salted caramel, pound cake, cinnamon sprinkle
  • Fruit salad: strawberry sauce, blackberries, pineapple, bananas, coconut, almonds
  • Southern Belle: peach jam, blackberries, salted pecans, pound cake

Chocolate Ice Cream Base:

  • S'mores: marshmallow, pecans, crumbled cone pieces
  • Ballpark: caramel, peanuts, dark chocolate bits
  • Peanut Butter Bliss: hot fudge, peanut butter cups, peanuts
  • Chocolate covered strawberry: strawberry sauce, fresh strawberries, chocolate bar, salted pecans
  • Candy Bar: hot fudge, caramel, pecans, shredded coconut, chocolate bar
  • Brownie Bliss: marshmallow, brownies, chocolate bar
  • The Elvis: hot fudge, banana, peanut butter cups
  • Birthday Cake: hot fudge, pound cake, whipped cream, sprinkles
  • German Chocolate Cake: hot fudge, walnuts, coconut, brownies
  • Mudd Pie: hot fudge, Oreos, peanut butter cups, almonds

4 Comments

  1. Pingback: 10 semi homemade Christmas cookies that will save your sanity - Peanut Blossom
  2. Pingback: Fire up the stove and get ready to rumble! Kitchen Cook-off for Kids - Peanut Blossom
  3. It will be a nice afternoon treat for the kids. Thank you for sharing the idea. I just can't wait to try it.

  4. Amazing. The ice cream would be more delicious when it is kept in an ice cream cooler or refrigerator. One would love to enjoy this type of ice creams in these summer days. 🙂

Share Your Thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *