The Best Bread Machine for Beginners
Looking for the best bread machine on the market for your family? If you're a beginner baker who wants help making homemade bread, find your perfect bread maker match in our extensive review of the most popular models available now.
Over the course of four months, our family baked hundreds of bread machine recipes while I wrote The Ultimate Bread Machine Cookbook.
We had five bread machines working two times a day, week after week. We learned all the ins and outs of every quirk and amazing feature of the most popular bread maker models available on the market right now.
If you're interested in buying a new bread machine so you can make warm, fresh, homemade bread and from-scratch dough for baking everything from dinner rolls to pretzels and cinnamon buns in your oven, you need to know which bread maker is the perfect fit for you.
Since every family has different priorities, I've done an extensive review of each bread machine model individually, but here I'm summarizing exactly which model is the best fit for individual needs.
Did I miss a question or concern that your family has? Let me know in the comments and I'd be happy to help you meet your perfect match.
The Contenders
While testing dozens upon dozens of bread maker recipes for The Ultimate Bread Machine Cookbook, my family and I tested the following bread machines for 6 months:
- Zojirushi Home Bakery Supreme Breadmaker
- Breville Custom Loaf Bread Machine
- Cuisinart Compact Bread Maker
- Hamilton Beach Bread Maker (Our model has been discontinued but their newest offering is listed here.)
- Amazon Basics Programmable Bread Maker
A Visual Comparison of Breads
Before I start awarding the "Best Of" titles, I think it is important for you to see the difference between the results of each of the main models we tested.
I baked the exact same bread machine Italian bread recipe in all the machines at the same time on the same day.
I measured each loaf exactly the same way with my food scale. Unfortunately, my container of yeast has started to expire so the domes of each loaf didn't get as perfectly round as they usually do, but even that result was pretty consistent across the board.
The Orientation of the Loaves:
In front of each machine, I've placed the bread in the orientation it bakes inside the machine:
Notice the bread on the far left: The space-saving Cuisinart bakes the loaf upright while the other models bake the bread in a more traditional orientation.
NOT PICTURED: The Amazon Basics bakes in the same orientation as the Cuisinart.
In the next photo, I've turned the Cuisinart loaf to match the orientation you would use to slice it for sandwiches as you would the other loaves:
For each loaf, I removed the mixing/kneading paddles before the rise cycle so that the loaves would bake without the paddle inside.
Even without the paddles baked inside, you will still get a small hole in the bottom of your bread where the paddle post remains:
Then I lined up each of the loaves more closely to one another to give you a better sense of size.
From Left to Right
Hamilton Beach:
This is not one of the top models I would recommend so it didn't appear in many of the photos above. The top of the bread is sunken in, but I promise that was a problem with my yeast and not the machine. You can still get a sense of the size and shape of the bread from the photo.
You can see why my husband disagrees and read the full Hamilton Beach bread machine review here.
Zojirushi:
The longest and narrowest of the loaves, this 2-pound bread is excellent for slicing.
Want to Save This for Later?
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
Cuisinart:
This 1.5-pound loaf has a consistent shape from end to end and is great for slicing. The yeast only caused a problem with the one side end and the mistake is easily hidden. It is a very forgiving bread machine for beginners.
Breville:
This 1.5-pound loaf still ended up close to perfect, despite the yeast causing problems in every other loaf that day.
Best Budget Bread Machine
If price is your greatest concern, your very best bet is the Amazon Basics Bread Machine.
The price can fluctuate but, especially during the holiday season, I have often seen it priced at less than $60.
It is nearly identical in many ways to the Cuisinart Compact but at less than half the price.
Best High-End Bread Machine
If price is no concern and you want a fancy bread machine with extra features, there's a little bit of disagreement on the winner.
I would recommend the Breville bread machine, my husband would suggest the Zojirushi bread maker. You'll want to check out the individual reviews before investing to see which one fits your family best.
Best Small Bread Maker
This is no contest. If space if your greatest concern, you will be happy with either the Amazon Basics or the Cuisinart Compact Bread Machine, they are nearly identical.
I love the size and shape of these handy little appliances.
However, if space matters most and price isn't as much of an issue for you, I think that the Cuisinart wins for being a better long-term investment. It is a sturdier machine that will hold up to years' worth of heavy baking.
Best at Baking Large Loaves
Go big or go home. If you want hearty 2-pound loaves each and every time, the Zojirushi bread maker is your match.
Most machines can bake up to 2-pound loaves but I have found them to be unwieldy and difficult to slice neatly. The bread pan on the Zojirushi makes a gorgeously shaped loaf that is perfect for slicing.
Best Loaf Shape
Not only does it do excellent large loaves, but the shape itself is definitely a winner. If you want breads from a bread machine that look like they were baked in an oven, the Zojirushi bread machine is your new best friend.
Best Machine for Storage
Don't like having a mess of appliances sitting on your counter all the time? If you want to be able to store your bread maker away in a kitchen cabinet or on a closet shelf, you absolutely want to get either the Cuisinart Compact Bread Machine or the Amazon Basics Bread Maker.
The machines are both compact in size and lightweight and easy to carry around. Either one will fit neatly anywhere you want to store it.
But again, if price is not as much of a concern for you as storage space, I recommend the Cuisinart as the better long term investment.
Best Dough Maker
Bread machines aren't just for baking bread. Some people prefer to finish the bread in their oven.
You can also make homemade dough in all the bread machine models we tested.
They all work great, but when we are mixing dough for bread machine pizza or homemade brown and serve dinner rolls, we tend to grab the Cuisinart compact bread maker because it is small, portable, and less noisy than other models.
Since the Amazon Basics works exactly the same as the Cuisinart, I think that it might win the contest for Best Dough Maker because you could run that motor on dough until it wears out and then really cheaply replace it.
Best for Small Families
If you're baking bread for 1 - 4 people, you don't need very large loaves. You're better baking smaller loaves more often so that your bread is as fresh as can be.
While that may sound like more work than it's worth, baking homemade bread in a bread machine only takes about 10 minutes of your time. You could easily pop a loaf in every few days as your family eats it.
For small loaves, I think either the Cuisinart compact bread machine or the Amazon Basics bread maker would be a perfect fit.
Best for Large Families
If you're baking bread for a family of 4 or more and they're using it up quickly on sandwiches, etc, you may need to make a larger loaf more frequently.
If you can consistently use up a 2-pound loaf and want a machine that is sturdy enough to meet high demand, you definitely want the Zojirushi bread machine.
Best for Flexibility
If you want to have the option to make a high-quality small loaf AND a high-quality large loaf AND amazing dough, the Breville bread machine is your very best option.
The texture, consistency, and flexibility of the bread pan makes it my favorite of all the machines. But, as with every model, it does have some cons that should be considered. Be sure to check the full review before you buy it.
Best for Working Parents
If you have a very busy family life and are only home for short periods of time, you need a bread machine that requires a minimum of oversight and produces consistent results.
While not completely perfect, the Cuisinart compact bread machine is your best option because you can keep an eye on it for the first 10 - 15 minutes and then the rest of the cycle is completely hands off.
However, if you're on a budget the Amazon Basics is also an excellent choice.
Ready to Jump In?
As the author of The Ultimate Bread Machine Cookbook, I'm very passionate about baking homemade bread with a bread maker.
If you're curious and wondering if a bread maker is worth it, not only do I think the answer is yes but I've got 50 amazing bread maker recipes for you to play with.
Don't miss this list of essential bread baking tools to go along with your new machine, too.
Hi, I recently borrowed a Panasonic bread machine from a friend that is awesome. It is discontinued:(. Anyway, I was trying to find another one I love. One of the things I love about this one is that the recipes do not call for extra gluten in any of the recipes and the bread turns out great. I used bread flour in one loaf and even did a whole wheat loaf that turned out perfect. Do you have to use extra gluten in these machines you reviewed for the bread to turn out well?
I never use extra gluten in any of our machines. We tried it during the recipe testing phase and didn't feel the extra ingredient cost was worth it.